Menu

Fall Menu

Fresh from our ovens daily • peteespie.com • @peteespie

Fresh Baked Pies

$7.99/slice ~ $45 whole

  • Hudson Valley Apple
  • Hudson Valley Apple Pecan Crumb*
  • NY Sour Cherry
  • NY Sour Cherry Pecan Crumb*
  • Wild Maine Blueberry
  • Wild Maine Blueberry Pecan Crumb*
  • Salty Chocolate Chess
  • Brown Butter Honey Pecan*
  • Coconut Custard

Ice Box Pies

$8.85/slice ~ $50 whole

  • Banana Cream
  • Lavish Chocolate Cream
  • Key Lime Meringue*

$8.85/slice ~ $55 whole

  • Petee's Cheesecake

Seasonal Specials

$7.99/slice ~ $45 whole

  • Concord Grape
  • Farm Fresh Pumpkin
  • Sweet Potato
  • Cherry Berry

$8.85/slice ~ $50 whole

Seasonal Specials

Ice Cream & Slice Cream

Housemade Vanilla Bean Ice Cream

$3 (4oz) / $9 (Pint)

Slice Cream

Housemade Vanilla Bean Ice Cream churned with chunks of:

  • Pecan Pie OR Salty Chocolate

$3 (4oz) / $9 (Pint)

Maple Whipped Cream

Housemade Whipped Cream with Vermont Maple Syrup, Vanilla, and a touch of salt

$3 (4oz) / $9 (Pint)

Available by the slice or whole

* Indicates items that may contain nuts

Menu items subject to availability • Prices subject to change