It's Pie Time ⏰

Note: Cutoff for next day orders are 3pm. If after 3PM call us at 212-966-2526.

If looking to order pies for Thanksgiving 11/24-/11/27 go here.

If looking to order pies for today go here instead.

Our Full Pie Line-up

Farm Fresh Pumpkin Pie 🆕 - Petee's Pie Co. Farm Fresh Pumpkin Pie 🆕 - Petee's Pie Co.
Farm Fresh Pumpkin Pie 🆕
$ 40.00
Sweet Potato 🆕 - Petee's Pie Co.
Sweet Potato 🆕
$ 40.00
Lavish chocolate cream pie with gold leaf chocolate flakes and whipped cream from Petee's NYC bakery Chocolate cream pie slice with bittersweet chocolate filling and gold leaf flakes at Petee's NYC
Lavish Chocolate Cream Pie
$ 50.00
Fresh banana cream pie with whipped cream topping and graham crust at Petee's Pie NYC bakery Banana cream pie slice with fresh banana filling and fluffy whipped cream from Petee's Pie Company NYC
Banana Cream
$ 50.00
Wild Maine blueberry pie with fresh blueberries and flaky crust baked daily at Petee's Pie NYC bakery Wild Maine blueberry pie slice with juicy blueberries and golden pastry crust from Petee's Pie Company NYC
Mixed Berry
$ 45.00
Guava mascarpone pie with tropical guava curd and purple blossoms from Petee's NYC bakery Tropical guava pie slice with whipped mascarpone and guava curd from Petee's Pie Company NYC
Guava Mascarpone Pie 🆕
$ 50.00
Classic lemon chess pie with golden custard filling and flaky crust from Petee's Pie Company NYC Lemon chess pie slice with creamy buttermilk custard and fresh lemon from Petee's NYC bakery
Classic Lemon Chess
$ 45.00
6-inch junior pies collection with apple, cherry and pecan flavors from Petee's NYC bakery Small batch junior pies in Hudson Valley apple and chocolate chess from Petee's Pie Company
Petee's Junior Pies
$ 20.00
Northern Spy Crispin apple pie golden butter crust Pete's Pie NYC artisanal bakery Hudson Valley apple pie slice with cinnamon filling and buttery crust from Petee's Pie Company NYC
Hudson Valley Heirloom Apple Pie
$ 45.00
Hudson Valley apple crumb pie with pecan cornmeal topping and brown sugar from Petee's NYC bakery Apple crumb pie slice with Hudson Valley apples and buttery pecan crumb from Petee's NYC
Hudson Valley Apple Crumb
$ 45.00
Fresh sour cherry pie with buttery crust made with tart cherries at Petee's Pie NYC bakery Sour cherry pie slice with ruby red filling and flaky pastry crust from Petee's Pie Company NYC
NY Sour Cherry Pie
$ 45.00
Sour cherry crumb pie with Montmorency cherries and pecan crumb topping from Petee's NYC bakery NY sour cherry crumb pie slice with tart cherries and buttery crumb from Petee's bakery NYC
Sour Cherry Crumb
$ 45.00
Wild Maine blueberry pie with fresh blueberries and flaky crust baked daily at Petee's Pie NYC bakery Wild Maine blueberry pie slice with juicy blueberries and golden pastry crust from Petee's Pie Company NYC
Wild Maine Blueberry
$ 45.00
Coconut custard pie with creamy coconut filling and toasted coconut flakes at Petee's Pie NYC bakery Coconut custard pie slice with silky custard filling and golden toasted coconut from Petee's Pie Company NYC
Coconut Custard
$ 45.00
Wild blueberry crumb pie with Maine berries and buttery crumb topping from Petee's NYC bakery Blueberry crumb pie slice with organic wild berries and pecan crumb from Petee's NYC
Wild Blueberry Crumb
$ 45.00
Salty chocolate chess pie with buttermilk custard, bittersweet chocolate and sea salt at Petee's Pie NYC bakery Chocolate chess pie slice with rich buttermilk filling, cocoa and sea salt from Petee's Pie Company NYC
Salty Chocolate Chess
$ 45.00
Black bottom almond chess pie with chocolate ganache base and buttermilk custard filling at Petee's Pie NYC bakery Black bottom almond chess pie slice with dark chocolate layer and rich buttermilk chess filling from Petee's Pie NYC
Black Bottom Almond Chess
$ 45.00
Brown butter honey pecan pie with caramelized pecans and flaky crust baked fresh at Petee's Pie NYC Brown butter honey pecan pie slice with golden filling and toasted pecans from Petee's Pie Company NYC
Brown Butter Honey Pecan
$ 45.00
Key lime meringue pie with fluffy toasted meringue and tart lime filling at Petee's Pie NYC bakery Key lime meringue pie slice with creamy key lime curd and golden meringue from Petee's Pie Company NYC
Key Lime Meringue
$ 50.00
Classic NY cheesecake with vanilla bean and orange zest made with Ben's cream cheese at Petee's NYC New York cheesecake slice with pie crust base and vanilla bean from Petee's bakery NYC
Classic NY Cheesecake
$ 55.00

Ice Cream and Whip Cream

Vanilla ice cream pint with salty chocolate pie chunks from Petee's NYC bakery Vanilla ice cream pint with buttermilk pie pieces from Petee's Pie Company NYC
Pint of Chocolate Chess Ice Cream
$ 9.00
Maple whip cream pint made with real maple syrup from Petee's Pie Company NYC bakery
Pint of Maple Whip Cream
$ 7.00
Brown butter honey pecan pie ice cream pint with pie chunks from Petee's NYC bakery Pecan pie ice cream pint with gooey pie pieces and NY honey from Petee's Pie Company
Pint of Pecan Pie Ice Cream
$ 9.00
Homemade vanilla bean ice cream pint with real vanilla beans from Petee's Pie Company NYC All-natural vanilla ice cream pint made with real vanilla bean pods at Petee's NYC bakery
Pint of Vanilla Ice Cream
$ 9.00